Hello dear
Welcome To Taste of New York Pizzeria
Taste of New York Pizzeria, located in Tampa, FL, captures the essence of authentic New York-style pizza with its perfect balance of crispy and chewy crusts, rich sauces, and generous toppings. Renowned for its welcoming atmosphere, the pizzeria doubles as a family-friendly destination, with accommodating staff and high chairs available for little ones. Popular menu items include savory garlic knots, flavorful rolls, and a variety of cold subs, all offered at affordable prices. Guests rave about the exceptional service and the restaurant's ability to satisfy even the pickiest eaters, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers seeking genuine flavors reminiscent of New York.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
12 Oz. Can Soda - 12 Oz. Can
US$2.59Veggie Pizza - Medium 14"
US$25.79Cheese Pizza - Large 16"
US$19.35
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza - Medium 14"
US$25.79Cheese Pizza - Medium 14"
US$18.05Mediterranean Pizza - Medium 14"
US$25.79
Special Pizza - Large 16"
US$27.09Eggplant Pizza - Large 16"
US$27.09Sicilian Special Pizza - Large 16"
US$29.65 About
Taste of New York Pizzeria
Welcome to Taste of New York Pizzeria—a delightful slice of New York City right in Tampa, Florida. Located at 17503-C Preserve Walk Ln, this charming pizzeria has quickly carved a niche for itself among pizza enthusiasts, and for good reason!
As soon as you step inside, the warm atmosphere envelops you, driven by the irresistible aroma of fresh pizzas baking in the oven. Whether you're a fan of the classic Margherita Pizza or prefer something a bit more adventurous like the Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, the offerings here promise to satisfy your craving for authentic New York-style pizza. Each pie is a delicate balance of crispy and chewy, topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients that bring every slice to life.
The Hawaiian Pizza, with its delightful combination of ham and pineapple, is a sunny escape on its own, while the Supreme Pizza bursts with flavor, thanks to its medley of pepperoni, beef sausage, and assorted veggies. For those who favor a heartier meal, there's the thick and satisfying Sicilian Cheese Pizza that delivers an indulgent experience with every bite.
But it’s not just the main dishes that make Taste of New York Pizzeria a must-visit; their appetizers are equally noteworthy. The Garlic Knots and Chicken Wings are crowd favorites, perfect for sharing or indulging in solo. In fact, customer reviews highlight the friendly service and the attention to detail when it comes to fulfilling special requests. As one satisfied customer, Michael Hall, shared, the staff truly listens to your needs to deliver a personalized experience.
Families will feel particularly at home here, as evidenced by Prasad Krishnan’s heartwarming review. The pizzeria exudes a genuine family-friendly ethos, with accommodating staff and a welcoming environment that makes dining out with little ones a breeze. Many parents appreciate the high chairs and kid-sized pizza options, ensuring every member of the family can enjoy a meal together without stress.
With affordable prices and generous portions, it’s no surprise that regulars like Mel Rodz are willing to make the drive for another bite of their deliciously authentic pizza. Whether you stop by for a quick slice or a family feast, Taste of New York Pizzeria aims to offer an experience that's about more than just food—it's about community, warmth, and exceptional flavors.
So the next time you're in Tampa and craving the vibrant flavors of New York-style pizza, make your way to Taste of New York Pizzeria. You won't just be enjoying a meal; you'll be part of a delicious culinary tradition. This pizzeria isn't just a dining spot; it’s a cherished escape that will leave your taste buds singing for more!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Perfect. Made a special request and they filled it perfectly. I want a crust between thin and pan, crispy and it was spot on. To know they actually follow the order matters. Now Uber didn’t bother to ring the doorbell and put my pie on the ground I can’t blame Taste of New York Pizzeria for that. I’ll just go in next time. ”
“ Best pizza I’ve had outside of newyork. Genuinely think. You can’t find any better. Pricing is the best I’ve seen in the area . And literally the best. This is my 3rd time coming here, I’ve done reheated slices and new pies and it never disappoints. Wish it was a little closer to where I live so I can come more after. ”
“ I was looking for good pizza and I found it. I ordered two slices of mushroom and a drink. I spent less than 8. The pizza was crispy, the the mushrooms were canned. I didn't mind the canned mushrooms. It's very hard to find good pizza in the tri-county area. This is one of the good ones. ”
“ A Slice of Heaven for the Whole Family (Especially the Little One!) Taste of New York Pizzeria isn't just a place to grab a fantastic slice; it's become a cherished family spot, and my toddler absolutely adores it! From the moment we walk in, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, the staff are always friendly and patient (which any parent with a busy little one knows is a HUGE plus!), and the aroma of baking pizza is simply divine. But the real magic happens when the pizza arrives. The crust is that perfect balance of crispy and chewy, the sauce is rich and flavorful without being overpowering, and the toppings are always fresh and generous. My little one, who can be a notoriously picky eater, devours their plain cheese slice with gusto every single time. It's become a ritual – "Pizza place!" is practically their favorite phrase. What makes Taste of New York truly stand out is how accommodating they are to families. They always have high chairs readily available, and the staff never bat an eye at the occasional toddler-induced mess (which, let's be honest, is inevitable). They even offer smaller slices that are perfect for little hands. Beyond the incredible food and service, there's a genuine, welcoming vibe that makes us feel like regulars. It's the kind of place where you can relax and enjoy a delicious meal without feeling stressed about having a toddler in tow. If you're looking for authentic, mouthwatering New York-style pizza and a family-friendly experience that will have even your littlest one asking for "more!", look no further than Taste of New York Pizzeria. It's a five-star experience through and through, and a weekly highlight for our family! We can't wait for our next visit! ”
“ Definitely need to try this Pizza place. First time eating here and WOW, definitely authentic New York style pizza. From the sauce, cheese down to the thin slice of pizza it was absolutely delicious. The service was on point, fast, kind and friendly. Prices are affordable and the servings are big. We will definitely will be driving the 15 minutes again to eat here. Thank you guys for a great meal and service. ”
“ Best true New York style pizza I’ve had since moving to Florida . Like where my parents went where I grew up. I come here anytime I want pizza. Friendly service, great NY style pizza . ”
“ A friend and I stumbled across a eatery called Taste of New York, serving Italian and Latin food. Being new in Kissimmee from Brooklyn, NY what luck. I could go on and on. The environment made me home sick especially the bathrooms. The decor was filled with NYC memories. The owners were wonderful and proud of the work they put in. I was offered a homemade NY slice of pizza which deserves return visits. The taste of garlic sets the pizza off! This eatery will be one of my favorites, I've eaten plenty of pizza across NYC, give this place a try. The Taste of New York will put you in a time machine especially if you are NYC kid! What a blessing. Tip well, the service is great! ”
“ I wanna start off by saying I am from New York and just moved out here not long ago. It’s hard to actually get a “taste of NY” here and I feel like tonight I really felt that I got it. I ordered stuffed shells w/ garlic knots and the Philly special I added lettuce tomato and mayo and let me tell you.... It was DELICIOUS. It took me back to up north. My partner shared it with me ( they’re from NJ ) and he felt the same exact way. We enjoyed it wholeheartedly, it was flavorful, fresh, hot and hit the spot. Also to note, great prices! We will be back soon for sure I would take this drive. I want to try the pizza and a lot of other things next time. Thank you again. ”